When Subscriber Growth Stalls, Let’s Reset | EP 229

Subscribe:  SarahsPodcast.com | Apple Podcast | Spotify | IHeartRadio | Stitcher

Every subscription box owner hits a wall. Growth slows down. The excitement you once felt starts to fade. You check your numbers and realize things have stalled.

Stalling doesn’t mean you’ve failed. It just means it’s time for a reset.

Most of the time, growth slows because you’ve either tapped out your current audience or haven’t been visible enough lately. The good news? You don’t have to overhaul everything. You just need to re-energize a few key areas to spark fresh momentum.

In this quick Friday Fuel episode of the Launch Your Box Podcast, I’m walking you through how to restart your momentum by focusing on three key areas that move the needle: growing your email list, showing up intentionally on social media, and running short, smart marketing bursts between launches.

Reset #1: Grow Your Email List (Again)

Your email list is your highest-converting asset, and when growth stalls, chances are your list has stalled, too.

Ask yourself: Am I actively growing my list this week?

If not, start here. Try a giveaway, launch a new lead magnet, or add a pop-up to your site. Promote your opt-in more often than feels comfortable. Remember, most people haven’t seen it yet!

Reset #2: Grow Your Following with Intention

People can’t buy from you if they don’t know you exist.

Audit your last six social media posts. Do they speak directly to your ideal subscriber? If not, shift your focus to connection:

• Share behind-the-scenes peeks of product selection or packing days.
• Spotlight subscriber stories or testimonials.
• Create simple reels using B-roll and overlay text.
• Share content that reflects your box’s niche or transformation.

Engagement comes first. Conversion follows.

Reset #3: Run Short-Burst Marketing Campaigns

You don’t need to wait for “launch week” to grow. Between launches, run small but mighty campaigns: 

• 3-day waitlist push
• Flash freebie bonus
• Subscriber referral challenge
• Simple paid ad paired with a short funnel sequence.

Think of these as mini-launches that keep your energy and your subscriber list growing all year long.

Bonus Reset Tips

If you’re ready to dig deeper, try these quick wins:

• Audit your list: scrub cold leads and segment by subscribers, leads, and past customers.
• Update your website: make sure it’s clear who your box is for and why they need it.
• Re-engage dormant leads: send a short, two-part reactivation sequence.
• Ask your audience: use Instagram polls or a quick quiz to find out what’s holding them back from subscribing.

Take Action

Choose one of these resets and take action today.

Whether it’s creating a new lead magnet, sharing a behind-the-scenes post, or running a 3-day waitlist push, do something that moves you closer to your next subscriber.

Join me for this episode of the Launch Your Box Podcast, where we’ll hit the reset button together and get your subscriber growth moving again, one simple action at a time.